My Kids Aren't That Special

Gifted or special needs seem to be the two educational extremes. What if your child falls into the “grey area?”

I have two boys.

The oldest, as are many first-born, is an over-achiever and thrives on praise and task completion. The youngest … well, let’s just say he’s got the gift of gab and aspires to be a professional circus clown when he grows up. Focus isn’t his strong suit.

As my oldest has progressed through his elementary school years, my husband and I have often struggled with the fact that he’s not being challenged as much as he could be in school. 

He’s pretty smart (in my motherly opinion), but he hasn’t been identified as ‘gifted’ even though some of his classmates are in a special group where they do fun and exciting things.

We’ve never pushed for that label – “gifted.” We don’t put value on that and truly just want him to learn at a pace that’s comfortable to him.

But we also know that he’s not working to the best of his ability because the opportunities just haven’t been offered to him from a school perspective. He’s smart, but maybe not noticeably smart enough.

On whom does this responsibility lie to offer extra support -- school district or parent?

We work with him after school to provide our own challenges -– making him do one or two more pages of math problems or conducting a science experiment with his dad who is also a middle school science teacher.

Several years ago we heard he was taking tests in the hall with a small group of other "smart" children. According to him, it was because they finished so much sooner than the rest of the class. We had to wonder if this was OK in the scheme of things.

Why was he being singled out for being smart in that instance, but not being offered more challenges in other parts of his school day?

Frankly, I was a little upset. Why should my son have to sit in the hall to take a test just because he understands the concepts?

I understand the workload a teacher carries. My husband teaches to all levels of learning abilities. But when he discovers students who are hungry for learning and want more, he gives them more. When he finds a student who is struggling, he thinks of new ways to work with them until they understand.

Our youngest son seems to fall to the opposite end of the spectrum. He appears to have a good handle on the concepts he should know as he enters kindergarten, but he struggles with his emotions and focus.

His preschool teacher suggested that a would benefit him. But after applying for this limited all-day offering, we were told he wasn’t accepted.

His "need" isn’t great enough to be considered. The other children being accepted to that class have bigger needs.

I’m nervous that he, too, will fall into the grey area of not having enough specialness to get the extra help he might actually need.

For our older son, it has been an issue of boredom. For our youngest, I’m concerned he will struggle academically and emotionally because he’s not needy enough to have that special support.

This is all speculation at this time, but after watching my oldest glide through elementary school with no one stepping up to say, “Hey! This kid has some brains. Maybe we can do some extra projects with him,” I have to wonder what's to come for our little guy.

And then I realize how many other children fall into the gray area.  Does yours?

Joel Shimer August 23, 2012 at 01:56 PM
Some of the same reasons why I don't miss Lincoln AT ALL! Wait until they get to Middle school....In my opinion its SO much better there. Your kids will also like that they can choose to be in the "Honors" class, or the "On Level" class. And Jenae, if you ever need info on teachers at Lincoln, we have ALOT to talk about:)
Victoria August 23, 2012 at 02:53 PM
My children are Swain School educated, no problems and exceptional learning, they will attend Central Catholic in Allentown for 9-12
Rosemary B August 23, 2012 at 04:45 PM
school choice is the way to go! One size does not fit all.
Jenae Holtzhafer August 23, 2012 at 07:19 PM
Thanks for all of these great ideas! We definitely do a lot with our boys at home (Legos, educational games, How It's Made (they love this - even my five-year-old)), but you offer some very interesting activities. Hobby Town is a great place! And I agree - sports offer a certain value, but experimenting and spending one-on-one time working on projects is also extremely valuable, not only educationally, but in building a parent-child bond that will be everlasting.
tracystough August 24, 2012 at 01:56 PM
very well put Kierstin:)


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »